metricas
covid
Buscar en
Vacunas
Toda la web
Inicio Vacunas Modeling the booster vaccine effect on new COVID-19 variant management employs t...
Información de la revista
Visitas
2
Original
Acceso a texto completo
Disponible online el 12 de junio de 2025
Modeling the booster vaccine effect on new COVID-19 variant management employs the Atangana-Baleanu-Caputo fractional derivative operator together with the Laplace-Adomian decomposition method
Modelar el efecto de la vacuna de recuerdo en el manejo de la nueva variante de la COVID-19 utiliza el factor derivativo fraccional de Atangana-Baleanu-Caputo junto con el método de descomposición de Laplace-Adomian
Visitas
2
M.O. Olayiwolaa, K.R. Tijania, M.O. Ogunnirana, A.O. Yunusa,
Autor para correspondencia
akeem.yunus@uniosun.edu.ng

Corresponding author.
, E.A. Oluwafemic, M.O. Abanikandab, A.I. Alajea, J.A. Adedejia
a Department of Mathematical Science, Osun State University, Osogbo, Nigeria
b Department of Science, Technology and Mathematics Education, Osun State University, Osogbo, Nigeria
c Department of Mathematics, Adeyemi Federal University of Education, Ondo, Nigeria
Este artículo ha recibido
Recibido 24 Febrero 2025. Aceptado 05 Mayo 2025
Información del artículo
Resumen
Texto completo
Bibliografía
Descargar PDF
Estadísticas
Figuras (8)
Mostrar másMostrar menos
Tablas (2)
Table 1. Definination of variable and parameter with values ans sources.
Tablas
Table 2. Parameters' values and sources.
Tablas
Mostrar másMostrar menos
Abstract
Introduction

New COVID-19 variants create worldwide health difficulties that call for effective control methods including booster vaccinations. The risk factors associated with new COVID-19 variants include enhanced transmission capabilities together with escape from immune responses and more severe disease manifestations which requires advanced vaccination measures. The developed mathematical model assesses how effectively booster vaccines help stop new COVID-19 variants from transmitting between people. Environmental variables that measure both public vaccine acceptance levels and widespread awareness levels integrated with the model to determine their roles in disease propagation rates. The research introduces fractional calculus to examine disease progress as well as booster vaccination effectiveness in stopping outbreaks.

Methods

This research establishes a fractional mathematical model to evaluate how booster vaccinations affect the spread of new COVID-19 variants. The stability evaluations and determination of basic reproduction number (R0) through next-generation matrix method form the basis of operational analysis for the model. Sensitivity analysis evaluates the effects that variable modifications have on disease outbreak controls. Evaluating complex fractional differential equations requires the analytical solutions derived by employing the Laplace-Adomian Decomposition Method (LADM). The solution approach provides accurate insights into equilibrium points as well as stability patterns together with control measures of disease transmission through vaccination strategies.

Results

Numerical data confirms the success of booster vaccination strategies because they lower transmission rates of infections and manage disease spread. Boosted vaccination rates lead to substantial decline in the basic reproduction number (R0) thus reducing disease transmission across the population. Sensitivity analysis shows how vaccine acceptance together with public awareness directly affects the maximum results achievable through booster doses. Success rates of vaccination programs heavily depend on behavioral elements which include vaccine hesitancy together with social perceptions about immunizations. The study demonstrates how vaccinating people alongside education programs leads to superior transmission control which supports long-lasting mitigation tactics.

Conclusion

The research evidence shows that booster vaccinations play a critical role in containing new COVID-19 variant spread. The research enables a full disease dynamics understanding through its integrated fractional-order model with behavioral components so it delivers effective vaccination optimization recommendations. Public health measures together with transmission control improve when people become more aware of vaccines. This developed model provides both scientific fundamentals for behavioral approaches in disease modeling and operational guidance to policy makers who need to create efficient vaccination programs. Booster vaccinations used together with awareness-raising programs establish a strong framework to manage the impact of new COVID-19 variants along with other infectious diseases.

Keywords:
Booster vaccine
COVID-19 variants
Atangana-Baleanu-Caputo fractional derivative
Laplace-Adomian decomposition method
Mathematical modeling
Resumen
Introducción

Las nuevas variantes de COVID-19 crean dificultades sanitarias a nivel mundial, que exigen métodos de control efectivo, incluyendo las vacunaciones de refuerzo. Los factores de riesgo asociados a las nuevas variantes de COVID-19 incluyen la mejora de las capacidades de transmisión junto al escape de las respuestas inmunitarias, así como más manifestaciones graves de la enfermedad que requieren medidas de vacunación avanzadas. El modelo matemático desarrollado evalúa el modo en que las vacunas de refuerzo ayudan a frenar la transmisión de las nuevas variantes de la COVID-19 entre las personas. Las variables ambientales que miden tanto los niveles de aceptación pública de la vacuna como los niveles de concienciación generalizada integrados con el modelo para determinar sus roles en la tasa de propagación de la enfermedad. La investigación introduce el cálculo fraccional para examinar el progreso de la enfermedad, así como la efectividad de la vacunación de refuerzo de cara a parar los brotes.

Métodos

Este estudio establece un modelo matemático fraccional para evaluar el modo en que las vacunaciones de refuerzo afectan a la propagación de las nuevas variantes de la COVID-19. Las evaluaciones de la estabilidad y la determinación del número básico de reproducción (R0) a través de un método matricial de nueva generación establecen la base del análisis operacional para el modelo. El análisis de sensibilidad evalúa los efectos que tienen las modificaciones variables en los controles de los brotes de la enfermedad. Evaluar las ecuaciones diferenciales complejas requiere las soluciones analíticas derivadas, utilizando LADM (Laplace-Adomian Decomposition Method). El enfoque de la solución aporta perspectivas precisas a los puntos de equilibrio, así como patrones de estabilidad, junto con medidas de control de la transmisión, mediante estrategias de vacunación.

Resultados

Los datos numéricos confirman el éxito de las estrategias de la vacunación de refuerzo, dado que reducen las tasas de transmisión de las infecciones y manejan la propagación de la enfermedad. Las tasas de la vacunación de refuerzo conducen a una reducción sustancial del número básico de reproducción (R0), disminuyendo así la transmisión de la enfermedad entre la población. El análisis de sensibilidad muestra el modo en que la aceptación de la vacuna, sumado a la concienciación pública, afecta directamente a los resultados máximos alcanzables mediante las dosis de refuerzo. Las tasas de éxito de los programas de vacunación dependen grandemente de los elementos conductuales, que incluyen la indecisión sobre la vacuna junto con las percepciones sociales acerca de las inmunizaciones. El estudio demuestra el modo en que la vacunación de las personas, junto con los programas educativos, conduce a un control superior de la transmisión que respalda las tácticas de mitigación a largo plazo.

Conclusión

La evidencia de la investigación muestra que las vacunaciones de refuerzo juegan un papel esencial en la contención de la propagación de las nuevas variantes de la COVID-19. La investigación permite comprender plenamente la dinámica de la enfermedad a través de su modelo de orden fraccional integrado con componentes conductuales, por lo que aporta recomendaciones de vacunación efectivas. Las medidas sanitarias públicas, junto con el control de la transmisión, mejoran el momento en que las personas adquieren más consciencia sobre las vacunas. Este modelo desarrollado proporciona tanto fundamentos científicos para los enfoques conductuales en la modelación de la enfermedad como una guía operativa para los formuladores de políticas, que necesitan crear programas de vacunación eficaz. Las vacunaciones de refuerzo, utilizadas junto con programas que susciten la concienciación, establecen un marco sólido para gestionar el impacto de las nuevas variantes de la COVID-19, junto con otras enfermedades infecciosas.

Palabras clave:
Vacuna de refuerzo
Variantes de la COVID-19
Factor derivativo fraccional de Atangana-Baleanu-Caputo
Método de descomposición de Laplace-Adomian
Modelación matemática
Texto completo
Introduction

The current pandemic control strategies face severe difficulties because of the fast development of new COVID-19 virus variants. Public health systems face difficulties when dealing with new COVID-19 variants because these variants possess higher transmission rates and escape immune responses and exhibit improved resistance to available treatments. Time-induced immune decay after primary vaccination drives medical authorities to deliver booster doses for the maintenance of protection against severe COVID-19 infections. Medical experts constitute booster vaccination one of the key methods for minimizing both hospital stays and severe COVID-19 instances and death counts during this pandemic.1–4 The precise timing and repetition pattern together with the general effects of booster vaccinations need additional detailed mathematical modeling to find proper solutions. A research team investigated 1,175,277 SARS-CoV-2 patients in Hong Kong to prove vaccinated populations experienced fewer deaths and heart issues whereas unvaccinated patients endured additional health problems.5–8 Research performed on 2686 immunosuppressed patients after vaccination showed 12% were without antibodies while 27% presented low antibody levels and patients experiencing severe COVID-19 demonstrated weaker immune responses prompting the requirement of specific therapeutic interventions.9 A research by10 investigated The VE of COVID-19 vaccines for Lebanese military personnel from 2021 through 2022. The effectiveness of VE decreased most notably following Omicron but nonetheless protected people from severe sickness. The vaccine provided by Pfizer generated stronger immune responses than Sinopharm while mixed vaccine sequences produced equivalent results. The results show that scientists should maintain continuous vaccine surveillance due to evolving variants.

Mathematical disease modeling stands essential for understanding how diseases spread and it helps assess different control methods. Integer-order differential models which represent traditional approaches in epidemiological studies lack ability to include memory effects caused by disease transmission. The solution of fractional differential equations depends on effective mathematical methods. Experts understand LADM as one of the most effective methods to produce approximated analytical solutions for nonlinear fractional models.11–21. The Atangana-Baleanu-Caputo (ABC) fractional derivative along with other fractional-order derivatives delivers an improved modeling technique for infectious diseases since it incorporates memory-dependent and non-local effects. The method improves predictive abilities since it creates more realistic descriptions of complex epidemiological processes22–28 thus becoming suitable for analyzing enduring COVID-19 dynamics. This research develops an advanced mathematical analysis through fusion of ABC fractional derivatives with LADM for studying booster vaccine effects on new COVID-19 strains. The study adds to pandemic control efforts through a theoretical model that helps maximize booster vaccination strategy effectiveness. The study provides critical information to policy makers regarding how booster vaccines boost epidemic control while decreasing transmission rates between individuals during the continuous evolution of COVID-19 variants.

Preliminary

This paper presents a fundamental approach to fractional operators of the Atangana-Baleanu Caputo (ABC) derivative.

Fundamental 128: Function ς∈Χ1uv,u

ABC define tABCDϑℵit=ABC1−ϕ∫0tρωXφ−ϕ1−ϕt−ωφdϕ,n−1<ϕ

Let tABCDϑςit=Hiℵ1ℵ2ℵ3⋯ℵi+Miℵ1ℵ2ℵ3⋯ℵi.be a function.

Implies Diϑ0=ςki, ∀i=1,2,3…m,ni−1≤ϑ≤ni.

equation above function also applying definition above

unknown function is decomposed the Adomian decomposition method, as:

Niℵ1…ℵi=∑j=0∞Cijt,i=1,2,…m.

So we:

By taking inverse of Laplace transform:

MethodsMathematical model formulation

The most current and prevalent strain of SARS-CoV-2, the XEC Covid-19 variation, and multiple-dose vaccination approaches are examined in this section along with the coronavirus transmission dynamics model. To more precisely ascertain the disease dynamics scenario, the total population, N, is separated into seven compartments that do not overlap. To strengthen the efficiency of the coronavirus vaccine and health vaccination against the disease, a booster dosage of the vaccine is required.29 Individuals who are susceptible (S), vaccinated with the first, second, or booster doses (V1, V2, Vb), exposed (E), infected (I), and recovered (R) are the dynamic variables that are taken into consideration. These variables are mutually exclusive. The equation N = S + V1 + V2 + Vb + E + I + R represents the population's total number (N), which is thought to be constant and evenly distributed.

We take into account appropriate transmission rate parameters related to each compartment when designing the coronavirus's dynamic process. Each compartment includes the natural death rate, which is constant at μ per capita, and the rate of entry into the population (Π). In contrast, the infected compartment includes the mortality rate from the severe health crisis, which was θ. Individuals who get the first dose of the vaccination against the XEC Covid-19 variant at a constant rate ξ are moved to the V1 compartment. Additionally, individuals who receive the first dose of the vaccination have a reduced probability of contracting the infection again at the rate ψ. Those who received the first dosage of the vaccination receive the second dose at a steady pace τ.

A number of people shift to the R compartment at a rate of φ1 after receiving a second dose of the XEC Covid-19 vaccine. After receiving the booster dose at a steady pace φ2, the second-dose recipients proceed to the R compartment at a rate υ. The most sensitive metric for virus spread is the transmission rate β, which is used to infect people. A number of people transfer to the infected compartment and carry the virus at the rate ε from the exposed individuals. Some patients reach the recovery stage and recover from the disease at a rate of γ after getting the right medical care. A system of ordinary differential equations can be used to track the dynamics of disease transmission. A detailed description of the system of differential equations for the dynamic variables under consideration is given:

People transition to the R compartment through a process that occurs at a rate of φ1 after their completion of the XEC COVID-19 vaccine series. The individuals move from R to the R compartment through the rate φ2, when receiving another booster dose at a steady pace and transition to the R compartment through rate υ. The transmission rate β, contains the highest significance for spreading disease as it controls the rate at which new infections occur. The passage from exposure to the infected compartment happens through virus carrying at the rate υ. Medical care patients experience recovery at the rate γ Ordinary differential equations create models to describe disease transmission by representing the main variables and their behavioral trends over time, below are variables and parameters explanation in Table 1.

  • 1.

    Invariant Region

Table 1.

Definination of variable and parameter with values ans sources.

Variable/Parameter  Description 
Count of Susceptible People 
V1  Count of First-dose Vaccinated People 
V2  Count of Second-dose Vaccinated People 
Vb  Count of Booster-dose Vaccinated People 
Count of Exposed People 
Count of Infected People 
Count of Recovered People 
μ  Rate at which people die naturally 
ξ  First-dose vaccination rate 
β  Transmission rate of the disease 
τ  Rate of second-dose vaccination 
φ1  Rate of recovery from the second-dose vaccination 
φ2  Rate of booster-dose vaccination 
Π  Rate of recruitment into the population 
μ  Rate at which people give up naturally 
ψ  Rate of transmission from V1 to S 
ν  Rate of recovery from booster-dose vaccination 
ε  Progression rate from exposed to infected compartment 
θ  Disease death rate induced 
γ  Recovery rate from infected compartment 

Theorem: The analytical solutions obtained for Eq. (1) are viable within the parameter space Φ for t≥0.

Proof: Total population be defined as N=S+V1+V2+Vb+E+I+R.

Then, we have:

Simplified dNdt=Π−μN,:

further to get:

N≤Πμ−Π−μNμe−μt, as t→∞,we have N≤Πμ..

Thus, the proposed model can be analyzed within the feasible region. Φ=SV1V2VbEIR∈R7:N≤Πμ.

  • 2.

    Positivity and boundedness of the Covid-19 model

Theorem: Given S>0,V1>0,V2>0,Vb>0,E>0,I>0,R>0,SV1V2VbEIR∈R7:N≤Πμ are positively invariant for t≥0..

Proof:

dSdt≥−βSI−ξS−μS⇒dSdt≥−βI+ξ+μS.

∫1SdS≥∫−βI+ξ+μdt,S≥S0e−βI+ξ+μt≥0.

Applying as follows:

and R≥r0e−μt≥0.
  • 3.

    Disease-free equilibrium (DFE)

The concept of DFE is essential in the analysis of epidemic models. It signifies a state in which the disease is absent from the community (E=I=0), meaning that no individuals are currently infected with the disease. Analyzing the DFE helps researchers to understand when a disease can be eliminated and the variables that inhibit an outbreak from spreading throughout the community.

Let dSdt=dV1dt=dV2dt=dVbdt=dEdt=dIdt=dRdt=0

and for S=V1=V2=Vb=E=I=R=0, DFE is given by:

  • 4.

    Endemic equilibrium (EE)

The EE represents a steady state where the ailment continues in the population at a constant level. Unlike the DFE, the EE does not lead to the eradication of the disease; instead, it results in a stable level of infection that can be sustained over time. At endemic equilibrium E=I≠0, which shows the persistence of the disease. Let the unique EE points of the model be denoted by E1=S∗V1∗V2∗Vb∗E∗I∗R∗. The result for each can be obtained as follows:

S∗=γ+μ+θμ+εβε,V1∗=γ+μ+θμ+εβψ+τ+μ,V2∗=τγ+μ+θμ+εβψ+τ+μφ1+φ2+μ,Vb∗=φ2τγ+μ+θμ+εβψ+τ+μφ1+φ2+μμ+ν,

  • 5.

    Basic reproductive numberR0

The basic reproduction number R0 represents an essential epidemiological value which predicts the amount of new cases that one infection would spread when it encounters a population that remains entirely vulnerable. The disease transmission possibility in communities becomes possible to estimate through this tool. The mathematical computation uses the next generation matrix approach to evaluate the disease classes E and R of the model. The disease remains active because of transmission factor R0 but ceases to exist when factor becomes zero.

R0=σFV−1 such that σ is the spectral radius,

F=f1f2=βSI0 and V=v1v2=μ+εE−εE+γ+θ+μI.

The matrix of FandVcan be obtained by differentiating with respect to EandI. At E0,

F=0βS00=0βΠε+μ00 and V=ε+μ0−εγ+θ+μ..

Finding the inverse of V,FV−1=βΠεμ+ε2γ+θ+μβΠε+μγ+θ+μ00..

Hence, R0=βΠεμ+ε2γ+θ+μ.

  • 6.

    Sensitivity analysis

We can obtain the sensitivity indices of all parameters in R0 by making use ϒR0X=∂R0∂X×XR0.

where X=βΠεγμθ and R0=βΠεμ+ε2γ+θ+μ..

Taking the parameters one after the other, we have the following by Maple 18 software package:

∂R0∂β×βR0=1,∂R0∂Π×ΠR0=1,∂R0∂ε×εR0=0.09090909127,

∂R0∂γ×γR0=−0.20000000, ∂R0∂μ×μR0=−1.690909091,∂R0∂θ×θR0=−0.20000000.

The ABC Covid-19 Model

Subject to:

According to Atangana and Owolabi's theory, we can use the ABC fractional integral to transform system1 into a voltera-type integral equation as follows:

Theorem: The kernels Ω1,Ω2,Ω3,Ω4,Ω5,Ω6,Ω7 in (2) satisfy the Lipschitz condition and contraction if the following inequality hold: 0≤η1,η2,η3,η4,η5,η6,η7<1..

Proof. Let Ω1tS=Π−βSI−ξS−μS+ψV1 and let kernels S1 and S2 be two functions, then we obtain the following.

where k1=βI+ξ+μ. Similarly, we get:
where k2=ψ+τ+μ,k3=φ1+φ2+μ,k4=μ+ν,k5=ε+μ,k6=γ+θ+μ and k7=μ.

The kernel of the Model, Eq. (1) can be expressed as:

Following recursive formula:

Next, we obtain the distinction between the expression's iterative terms.

Sn=∑n=0∞Θ1n,V1n=∑n=0∞Θ2n,V2n=∑n=0∞Θ3n,Vbn=∑n=0∞Θ4n,En=∑n=0∞Θ5n,In=∑n=0∞Θ6n and Rn=∑n=0∞Θ7n.

Applying triangular inequality and the norms on (7), we have:

These kernels satisfies the Lipschitz condition yielding the following:

Theorem: A solution to (2) exists if there is a tmax satisfying kiHω1−ω+tmaxωΓω such that i∈123…7..

Proof: Suppose S,V1,V2,Vb,E,I and R are bounded functions, we can apply the following relation to2:

Hence, Θkn, for k=1…7 in (8) exists. Also, to show that, Θkn, for k=1…7 are the solution of (2), we can construct:

where Δkn,k=1…7 are the residual terms of the series solution. Thus, as the term approaches infinity, Δk∞→0,k=1…7. Thus, for the term Δ1n,Θ1n≤1−ωHωΩ1tSn−1−Ω1(tSn−2)+ωHωΓω∫0tt−Θω−1Ω1(tSn−1Θ)−Ω1(tSn−2Θ)dΘ,

Continuing this way recursively, we get:

Θ1n≤Bk1nk1Hω1−ω+tmaxωΓωn+1, where B=S−Sn−1. Taking the limit of both sides as n→∞, we get:

  • 7.

    Stability analysis of the ABC Covid-19 model

We proved the stability of (2) here by using stability criteria of Ulam-Hyers and Generalized Ulam-Hyers.

Suppose ε>0, we can look into:

where ε=maxεiT,i=1,…,7. Such that Μtϑ is the compact form of (2).

Definition 1. Let f:R→R, If there exist DΜ>0 and for all ε>0, a solution x¯∈R satisfying (10), then (2) is Ulam-Hyers stable if there exist x∈R of (2) with:

x¯−x≤DΜε,t∈ℕ, where DΜ=maxDΜiT.

Let x¯∈R satisfy:

for y∈Y such that,
and

Theorem 5. If x¯∈ℕ satisfy:

x¯ will then satisfies,

Proof.D0ABCtωx¯=Μtx¯+yt, and for:

We can use Mtx≤εt,∀tx∈ℕ×R7 and Eq. (11) to get:

Theorem 6. Let M:ℕ×R7→R be continuous for every x∈R, if there exist (14) with 1−ΨKΜ>0,(2) is then said to be Ulam-Hyers and afterward Ulam-Hyers stable.

Proof. Let x¯∈R satisfy (11) and x¯∈R is a unique solution of (2) using (10) and for all ε>0 we have:

This means that x¯−x≤DΜε such that DΜ=Ψ1−ΨKΜ. So, for ϕΜε=DΜε such that ϕΜ0=0. So, (2) is Ulam-Hyers stable.

  • 8.

    Application of LADM

Here, we solved (2) using the Laplace Adomian Decomposition Method (LADM).

Simplifying,

Taking the inverse Laplace transform of (11), we obtain:

The model variables of12 can be represented as follows:

The nonlinear term can be decomposed as follows by Adomian:

By Eqs. (13) and (14), we have:

Let S0=m1,V10=m2,V20=m3,Vb0=m4,E0=m5,I0=m6,R0=m7, then Eq. (15) becomes:

The approximate solution is assumed as n→∞. So, S=limn→∞Sn,V1=limn→∞V1n,V2=limn→∞V2n,Vb=limn→∞Vbn,E=limn→∞En,I=limn→∞In,R=limn→∞Rn.

When n=0, using Mathematica 11 software package, Eq. (16) gives:

When n=1, Eq. (16) gives:

Results

By fitting the model's parameters and the initial values as indicated in Table 2, we are able to display the compartments' solution of the model.

(See Table 1: Definiation of variable and parameter.)

Table 2.

Parameters' values and sources.

Parameters  Values  References 
β  2.55  30 
ε  0.25  30 
γ  0.1  31 
ψ  0.095  31 
ξ  0.83  30 
φ1  0.8  31 
θ  0.1  30 
φ2  0.8  31 
μ  0.0143  31 
τ  0.75  31 
Π  750  32 
47,020  30 
V1  700  32 
V2  500  32 
Vb  555  32 
2003  30 
416  30 
115  30 
Numerical simulation

See Figs. 1–8.

Fig. 1.

Column graph showing the sensitivity indices of parameters in R0.

(0.19MB).
Fig. 2.

Contour plot of R0 as a function of β,ε,θ and μ.

(0.18MB).
Fig. 3.

Effects of various parameters in R0 on the spread of XEC Covid-19 variation.

(0.47MB).
Fig. 4.

Effects of long and short memory on each compartments of the Covid-19 model.

(0.66MB).
Fig. 5.

Effect of transmission from V1 to S on the susceptible population.

(0.12MB).
Fig. 6.

Effect of rate recovery from booster-dose vaccination on recovered population.

(0.14MB).
Fig. 7.

3D Analysis of susceptible population dynamics as a function of ξ and ψ.

(0.16MB).
Fig. 8.

3D Analysis of Recovered Population as a function of φ1 and ν.

(0.3MB).
Discussion

Fig. 1 shows the column graph of the sensitivity indices of parameters in R0. It depicts how each parameters ranges within the boundary of the sensitivity indices. Fig. 2A shows contour lines that represent constant values of R0. Lower values of β and ε result in a lower R0. Higher values of β and ε lead to higher R0. The trend suggests that both parameters positively contribute to R0, meaning a higher transmission rate or progression rate increases the reproductive potential of the disease. Fig. 2B shows contour lines that represent constant values of R0. Lower values of θ and μ result in a higher R0. Higher values of θ and μ lead to lower R0. The trend suggests that both parameters meaningfully contribute to R0, meaning a higher disease-induced death and natural death lead to decrease in the reproductive potential of the disease. Fig. 3 shows the effects of various parameters in R0 on the spread of XEC Covid-19 variation. (A) and (B) show direct relationship between R0 and β or Π. It simply means that R0 increases as β or Π increases. C, D and F show downward trend as the parameter increases. It means that R0 decreases as the values of the parameter increases. (E) shows a nonlinear relationship R0 and progression rate. The shape of the graph suggests that an intermediate progression rate results into increasing R0. Fig. 4(A–G) shows the effects of long and short memory on each compartment of the model. Population of each compartment either declines or ascends more gradually at ω=0.7. This implies a longer memory effect, meaning past states influence the present more strongly. Disease transmission occurs at a slower rate because the system “remembers” past interactions more significantly. Also, population of each compartment either declines or ascends faster at ω=1. This corresponds to a shorter memory effect, meaning recent events dominate the dynamics. The system behaves more like a classical integer-order model, where past states have little influence on the present. At ω=0.8 and ω=0.9, the rate of decline is between the extreme cases. The memory effect gradually weakens as ω increases. Fig. 5 shows the effect of transmission from V1 to S on the susceptible population. The graph shows an upward trend as the rate of transmission increases. It implies that susceptible population increases as more people joined after receiving the first-dose of vaccine. Fig. 6 shows the effect of rate of recovery from booster-dose vaccination on recovered population. The graph shows an upward trend as the recovery rate increases. It means that more patients recovered after receiving the booster-dose. Patients who recovered at this stage are no longer susceptible to the virus. Fig. 7 shows the 3D analysis of susceptible population dynamics as a function of ξ and ψ. The relationship suggests a direct influence of these parameters on susceptibility. Fig. 8 shows the 3D analysis of recovered population as a function of φ1 and ν. The relationship suggests a direct influence of these parameters on recovered population.

Conclusion

Current evidence shows that new variants of COVID-19 emphasize the need for strong strategies like booster vaccinations to maintain control. The research created a mathematical model through the Atangana-Baleanu-Caputo fractional derivative operator because it improves disease dynamics modeling by considering temporal memory effects. Through the use of Laplace-Adomian Decomposition Method analysts derived analytical approximations which enhanced our comprehension of booster vaccination effects on infection transportation and disease equilibrium. Research demonstrates that booster vaccination plays an essential part in both disease containment and better recovery statistics. Sensitivity analysis verified vital elements of R0 through which transmission factors and disease progression directly control epidemic potential. Numerical modeling experiments demonstrated booster vaccines create higher population protection which decreases disease evolution and makes infection less likely.The research findings showed that longer memory duration reduced disease transmission but shorter memory duration caused faster disease course changes. Booster vaccination caused two beneficial changes in population statistics which graphical analysis demonstrated: it boosted recovery rates and decreased the number of people who were susceptible to infection. The findings from this study support decision-makers who need to develop optimal vaccination policies for managing new COVID-19 variant spread. Research needs to analyze authentic data alongside advanced fractional-order modeling analysis to achieve optimal prediction precision and public health response enhancement.

Acknowledgments

Prof. M. O Olayiwola and other authors greatly appreciate the Tertiary Education Trust Fund (TET Fund) for providing conference attendance grant for this research under the year 2024 TETFund Conference Attendance Grant.

References
[1]
World Health Organization (WHO). COVID-19: variants and their impact on public health measures. WHO Report; 2023.
[2]
I.C.H. Lam, R. Zhang, K.K.C. Man, C.K.H. Wong, C.S.L. Chui, F.T.T. Lai, E.Y.F. Wan.
Persistence in risk and effect of COVID-19 vaccination on long-term health consequences after SARS-CoV-2 infection.
Nat Commun, 15 (2024), pp. 1716
[3]
H.J. Park, G.S. Gonsalves, S.T. Tan, J.D. Kelly, G.W. Rutherford, R.M. Wachter, N.C. Lo.
Comparing frequency of booster vaccination to prevent severe COVID-19 by risk group in the United States.
[4]
S.L. Kelly, E.A. Le Rutte, M. Richter, M.A. Penny, A.J. Shattock.
COVID-19 vaccine booster strategies in light of emerging viral variants: frequency, timing, and target groups.
[5]
B.J. Gardner, A.M. Kilpatrick.
Third doses of COVID-19 vaccines reduce infection and transmission of SARS-CoV-2 and could prevent future surges in some populations: a modeling study.
[6]
Y.M. Bar-On, Y. Goldberg, M. Mandel, O. Bodenheimer, L. Freedman, N. Kalkstein, A. Huppert.
Protection of BNT162b2 vaccine booster against Covid-19 in Israel.
[7]
H.M. Rando, R. Lordan, A.J. Lee, et al.
Application of traditional vaccine development strategies to SARS-CoV-2.
Msystems, 8 (2023),
[8]
R.J.D. Sorensen, R.M. Barber, D.M. Pigott, A. Carter, C.N. Spencer, S.M. Ostroff, C. Murray.
Variation in the COVID-19 infection-fatality ratio by age, time, and geography during the pre-vaccine era: a systematic analysis.
The Lancet, 399 (2022), pp. 1469-1488
[9]
E. Barnes, C.S. Goodyear, M. Willicombe, et al.
SARS-CoV-2-specific immune responses and clinical outcomes after COVID-19 vaccination in patients with immune-suppressive disease.
[10]
R. Moghnieh, W. Haddad, N. Jbeily, S. El-Hassan, S. Eid, H. Baba, M.H. Sayegh.
Immunogenicity and real-world effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines in Lebanon: insights from primary and booster schemes, variants, infections, and hospitalization.
PloS One, 19 (2024),
[11]
M.O. Olayiwola, A.O. Yunus.
Mathematical analysis of a within-host dengue virus dynamics model with adaptive immunity using Caputo fractional-order derivatives.
J Umm Al-Qura Univ Appl Sci, 11 (2024), pp. 1-20
[12]
A.O. Yunus, M.A. Omoloye.
Mathematical analysis of efficacy of condom as a contraceptive on the transmission of chlamydia disease.
Int J Comput Sci Mobile Appl, 10 (2022), pp. 22-37
[13]
A.O. Yunus, M.O. Olayiwola, M.A. Omoloye, A.O. Oladapo.
A fractional order model of Lassa disease using the Laplace-Adomian decomposition method.
Health Anal J, 3 (2023), pp. 100167
[14]
A.O. Yunus, M.O. Olayiwola.
The analysis of a novel COVID-19 model with the fractional-order incorporating the impact of the vaccination campaign in Nigeria via the Laplace-Adomian decomposition method.
J Nigerian Soc Phys Sci, 6 (2024), pp. 1830
[15]
A.I. Alaje, M.O. Olayiwola.
A fractional-order mathematical model for examining the spatiotemporal spread of COVID-19 in the presence of vaccine distribution.
[16]
M.O. Olayiwola, A.I. Alaje, A.Y. Olarewaju, K.A. Adedokun.
A caputo fractional order epidemic model for evaluating the effectiveness of high-risk quarantine and vaccination strategies on the spread of COVID-19.
Healthc Anal, 3 (2023),
[17]
A.O. Yunus, M.O. Olayiwola, K.A. Adedokun, J.A. Adedeji, I.A. Alaje.
Mathematical analysis of fractional-order Caputo's derivative of coronavirus disease model via Laplace Adomian decomposition method.
Beni-Suef Univ J Basic Appl Sci, 11 (2022), pp. 144
[18]
M.O. Olayiwola, A.I. Alaje, A.O. Yunus.
A caputo fractional order financial mathematical model analyzing the impact of an adaptive minimum interest rate and maximum investment demand.
Results Control Optimiz, 14 (2024),
[19]
A.O. Yunus, M.O. Olayiwola.
Mathematical modeling of malaria epidemic dynamics with enlightenment and therapy intervention using the Laplace-Adomian decomposition method and Caputo fractional order.
Franklin Open, 8 (2024),
[20]
A.O. Yunus, M.O. Olayiwola, A.M. Ajileye.
A fractional mathematical model for controlling and understanding transmission dynamics in computer virus management systems.
Jambura J Biomath (JJBM), 5 (2024), pp. 116-131
[21]
A.O. Yunus, M.O. Olayiwola.
The analysis of a co-dynamic ebola and malaria transmission model using the Laplace adomian decomposition method with caputo fractional-order.
Tanzania J Sci, 50 (2024), pp. 224-243
[22]
A. Atangana, J.F. Gómez-Aguilar.
Numerical approximation of Riemann-Liouville definition of fractional derivative: From Riemann-Liouville to Atangana-Baleanu.
Numer Methods Part Diff Eq, 34 (2018), pp. 1502-1523
[23]
O.J.J. Algahtani.
Comparing the Atangana–Baleanu and Caputo–Fabrizio derivative with fractional order: Allen Cahn model.
Chaos Solit Fract, 89 (2016), pp. 552-559
[24]
M. Al-Refai.
On weighted Atangana–Baleanu fractional operators.
Adv Diff Eq, 2020 (2020), pp. 3
[25]
M.A. Dokuyucu, D. Baleanu, E. Çelik.
Analysis of Keller-Segel model with Atangana-Baleanu fractional derivative.
Filomat, 32 (2018), pp. 5633-5643
[26]
H. Abboubakar, P. Kumar, N.A. Rangaig, S. Kumar.
A malaria model with Caputo–Fabrizio and Atangana–Baleanu derivatives.
Int J Model Simulat Sci Comput, 12 (2021),
[27]
M.A. Khan.
The dynamics of a new chaotic system through the Caputo–Fabrizio and Atanagan–Baleanu fractional operators.
Adv Mech Eng, 11 (2019),
[28]
M.O. Olayiwola, A.I. Alaje, A.O. Yunus.
Modelling the impact of education and memory on the management of diabetes mellitus using Atangana-Baleanu-Caputo fractional order model.
Nonlinear Dyn, 113 (2024), pp. 1-21
[29]
S. Chenchula, P. Karunakaran, S. Sharma, M. Chavan.
Current evidence on efficacy of COVID-19 booster dose vaccination against the omicron variant: a systematic review.
[30]
M.O. Olayiwola, A.O. Yunus.
Non-integer time fractional-order mathematical model of the COVID-19 pandemic impacts on the societal and economic aspects of Nigeria.
[31]
A.K. Paul, N. Basak, M.A. Kuddus.
Mathematical analysis and simulation of COVID-19 model with booster dose vaccination strategy in Bangladesh.
[32]
P. Pongsumpun, P. Pongsumpun, I.M. Tang, J. Lamwong.
The role of a vaccine booster for a fractional order model of the dynamic of COVID-19: a case study in Thailand.
Copyright © 2025. Elsevier España, S.L.U.. All rights reserved
Descargar PDF
Opciones de artículo
Herramientas
es en pt

¿Es usted profesional sanitario apto para prescribir o dispensar medicamentos?

Are you a health professional able to prescribe or dispense drugs?

Você é um profissional de saúde habilitado a prescrever ou dispensar medicamentos